Head to head · #1 vs #21

White Door Management vs Preach Agency

How we rank: 16 criteria with published weights, scored only from what each agency publishes on its own website or in a public register. The quote, the link and the date sit beside every score; anything not published scores 0. No agency pays to be listed or for its position. Methodology

#1 of 29

White Door Management

Ahead on: Login and 2FA stay with the creator, Payouts go straight to the creator, Content and pages stay the creator's and No minimum term, short notice, no exit fee (+11).

#21 of 29

Preach Agency

Ahead on: Longevity, documented.

White Door Management scores higher on 15 criteria, Preach Agency on 1, and 0 are level. White Door Management (9.3) ranks above Preach Agency (1.7): it scores higher on 15 criteria (login and 2fa stay with the creator, payouts go straight to the creator, content and pages stay the creator's, no minimum term, short notice, no exit fee and no commission after exit, …) and lower on 1 (longevity, documented).

Score by group

GroupWhite Door ManagementPreach Agency
Control (35%)10.01.0
Money (25%)10.02.5
Service evidence (25%)10.01.3
Verifiability (15%)5.32.3

White Door Management

Fits if you want to keep sole control of your login and 2FA, payouts must go straight to your own account and content ownership and the end of the licence at exit matter to you.

All 16 criteria side by side

CriterionWhite Door ManagementPreach AgencyEvidence
1. Login and 2FA stay with the creator100
Evidence

White Door Management: The account, logins, email, two-step verification, content and data always belong to the creator.

+1 more quoteWe work through team access the creator grants and can revoke at any moment. We never ask for the password and never change passwords or payout details.
Source: whitedoormgmt.com/en/guides/sample-term-sheet · checked 22 October 2026

Preach Agency: Nothing published on the pages we read.

2. Payouts go straight to the creator100
Evidence

White Door Management: Payouts go from the platform directly to the creator's own bank account. We never receive or hold the creator's payouts.Source: whitedoormgmt.com/en/guides/sample-term-sheet · checked 22 October 2026

Preach Agency: Nothing published on the pages we read.

3. Content and pages stay the creator's105
Evidence

White Door Management: The account, logins, email, two-step verification, content and data always belong to the creator.

+1 more quoteWe use content only to run the creator's account, in the ways the creator approves, and only while the agreement runs.
Source: whitedoormgmt.com/en/guides/sample-term-sheet · checked 22 October 2026

Preach Agency: You retain ownership of the content you createSource: preachagency.com · checked 22 October 2026

4. No minimum term, short notice, no exit fee100
Evidence

White Door Management: No minimum term and no automatic lock-in or renewal period.

+2 more quotesEither side can end the agreement with thirty days' notice, in writing (an email is enough).No penalties for leaving.
Source: whitedoormgmt.com/en/guides/sample-term-sheet · checked 22 October 2026

Preach Agency: Nothing published on the pages we read.

5. No commission after exit100
Evidence

White Door Management: No trailing commission. Commission applies only to net earnings during the agreement, up to its end. Nothing is charged afterwards.Source: whitedoormgmt.com/en/guides/sample-term-sheet · checked 22 October 2026

Preach Agency: Nothing published on the pages we read.

6. Commission published, with basis100
Evidence

White Door Management: Rate: 25–60% of net earnings. One range covers the full service; there is no separate price list per service.

+1 more quoteNet means the earnings that reach the creator after the platform's share
Source: whitedoormgmt.com/en/guides/sample-term-sheet · checked 22 October 2026

Preach Agency: A fixed percentage is not published on this websiteSource: preachagency.com · checked 22 October 2026

7. No upfront fees, scope itemized105
Evidence

White Door Management: No upfront costs, no set-up fees, no other fees. The commission is the only charge.

+1 more quoteReporting: a short daily note and a written weekly report covering revenue, conversations and every change made.
Source: whitedoormgmt.com/en/guides/sample-term-sheet · checked 22 October 2026

Preach Agency: Our published model does not require an upfront investment from creatorsSource: preachagency.com · checked 22 October 2026

8. Written reporting: cadence and sample100
Evidence

White Door Management: Every Monday: a written report with revenue by category, notable conversations and every change we made to prices, offers or schedule, with the reason.

+1 more quoteEvery creator we manage gets a short note each morning and a full written report every Monday. Below is the structure of that report.
Source: whitedoormgmt.com/en/guides/is-white-door-management-legi · checked 22 October 2026

Preach Agency: Nothing published on the pages we read.

9. Content protection included100
Evidence

White Door Management: A specialised partner provider checks for copies of your content every day and files the removal notices, so you never file one yourself.

+2 more quotesAbout one week on average, depending on the platform.We do not promise a fixed time, because no honest provider can.
Source: whitedoormgmt.com/en/guides/content-protection · checked 22 October 2026

Preach Agency: Nothing published on the pages we read.

10. Results with a way to verify103
Evidence

White Door Management: Monthly revenue after the platform's share and before our commission, taken from each creator's own payout records and shared with their permission.

+3 more quotesOne creator account, OnlyFans, 2 August 2022 to 22 October 2026: $3,550,315.18 gross, $2,840,058.81 net after the platform's share.Every record here is watermarked, anonymised and shared with the written consent of the creator.Our profile on TopAgencies, an agency directory, shows 7 creators verified by the directory.
Source: whitedoormgmt.com/en/guides/results · checked 22 October 2026

Preach Agency: This figure is a historical, self-reported outcomeSource: preachagency.com/success-stories/15-best-blogs-to-follow · checked 22 October 2026

11. Says who should not sign100
Evidence

White Door Management: Anyone looking for a one-off service, such as leak removal on its own or a single promotion push. We manage accounts, we do not sell parts.

+3 more quotesCreators who want guaranteed numbers. Nobody honest can promise a figure.Takedown subscription onlyCreators whose main problem is leaks.
Source: whitedoormgmt.com/en/guides/is-white-door-management-legi · checked 22 October 2026

Preach Agency: Nothing published on the pages we read.

12. Exit handover published100
Evidence

White Door Management: Access: our team access is removed at the end. The creator can withdraw it at any time anyway.

+4 more quotesReturn of everything we hold: the voice guide, fan notes, price list and any other material prepared for the account are handed to the creator straight away.When the agreement ends, account material is handed back and our copies are deleted, except where the law requires us to keep records such as invoices.Once your notice is processed, we log out of all your accounts and delete the creator data we hold, except records the law requires us to keep, such as invoices.The voice guide, fan notes, price list and any other material prepared for your account are handed back to you.
Source: whitedoormgmt.com/en/guides/sample-term-sheet · checked 22 October 2026

Preach Agency: Nothing published on the pages we read.

13. Chat policy published105
Evidence

White Door Management: Only people on our team. We use no AI to write messages.

+2 more quotesThey write in your voice, following a written voice guide and the boundaries you set with us before the start.We work in English and German. Fans who write in German are answered in German by people who write German, not by translated English.
Source: whitedoormgmt.com/en/guides/team · checked 22 October 2026

Preach Agency: Our subscriber chat service uses a dedicated team of operators

+1 more quoteYou can discuss communication expectations and your content boundaries with your account manager before the collaboration begins
Source: preachagency.com · checked 22 October 2026

14. Legal entity in a public register50
Evidence

White Door Management: White Door Management is operated by Kasir Consulting LLC, a limited liability company registered in Wyoming, USA, with its address at 1309 Coffeen Avenue STE 6289, Sheridan, WY 82801.Source: whitedoormgmt.com/en/guides/is-white-door-management-legi · checked 22 October 2026

Preach Agency: 30 N Gould ST STE NSource: preachagency.com · checked 22 October 2026

15. Longevity, documented17
Evidence

White Door Management: Oldest public record: domain registration (RDAP), 21 October 2026. Own founding claims do not count.Source: rdap.org/domain/whitedoormgmt.com · checked 22 October 2026

Preach Agency: Oldest public record: domain registration (RDAP), 9 October 2022. Own founding claims do not count.Source: rdap.verisign.com/com/v1/domain/preachagency.com · checked 22 October 2026

16. Scale published100
Evidence

White Door Management: White Door Management has over 100 people, including chatters and assistants, working in English and German.

+1 more quotePlatforms | OnlyFans and Fansly.
Source: whitedoormgmt.com/en/guides/team · checked 22 October 2026

Preach Agency: Nothing published on the pages we read.

Published facts side by side

FactWhite Door ManagementPreach Agency
Country / companyUS (Wyoming LLC)US (Wyoming address, no entity name)
Languages (published)English, GermanEnglish, German
PlatformsOnlyFans, Fansly—
Commission (published)25–60% of net—
Term and noticeno minimum term, 30 days' notice—
Oldest public record21 October 2026 (domain registration (RDAP))9 October 2022 (domain registration (RDAP))
Evidence checked22 October 202622 October 2026
Saved quotes37 · SHA-256 per page snapshot7 · SHA-256 per page snapshot

Related

Right of reply: any agency listed here can point us to a public page that changes a score. We re-read it and publish the result, dated, in the updates log. See corrections and right of reply.